FINALLY. Saw “The Artist” on Thursday night with film/AMP buddies (I’m the one in the middle looking weird).
Here’s my take…
I get why some people asked for their money back because they didn’t realize “The Artist” was a silent film. The silence is a little jarring. Even as a film minor still in college, I found it jarring. Part of this is that you’re in a movie theater and not a classroom watching this movie. You also know that sound is possible, so you kind of hope they’ll sneak something in there besides music. And you recognize a lot of the American actors, like John Goodman, and it’s weird seeing them in a black and white film without any sound.
Having said that, I think Michael Hazavanicius (writer and director) did a fabulous job! I remember reading an article about this movie last Spring and thinking that it could either be really bad or really good. In the theater I had the same thought, but instead it was “This could have been really awful if they did one thing wrong, but they got it just right.”
One part of how they got it right - they managed to use very minimal intertitles and still get the message across easily. From what I remember of some silent movies (especially the ones that attempted grandiose plots), there was much more of a dependence on intertitles. But this film is about embracing the power of film, sans dialogue and color. It’s about the power of the visual, the cinematography and the acting. I was actually reminded of the love story sequence in “Up,” which manages to make people (me) cry with animated looks and beautiful music.
Another part? The acting. Jean DuJardin embodies the old Hollywood actor. His smile is charming and disarming, every move he makes reminds you of Gene Kelly or Cary Grant. He seriously enchants this movie, and in my opinion, is a very large reason why it works. Also, in a very difficult (but perfect) move, they decided to give him a dog sidekick who steals the show. He adds the humor and the heartbreak.
This movie is an homage to old movies, paralleling movies like “Singin’ in the Rain” (which is also why you keep thinking they are going to talk). It is extremely meta – a silent movie about silent movies dying out and sound taking over, which can be confusing and fun when we see what the sound movies are supposed to look like.
So, do I recommend this movie? Absolutely.
To everyone? No. This will enchant true movie-lovers everywhere, and delight people who have a longer attention span, but I would not recommend this to people who need a lot of things going on to keep their attention.
Should it win the Oscar?
Although I haven’t seen some of the frontrunners (“The Descendants”), in the words of my friend Hannah – it should win just because of how unique it is. The fact that they pulled this kind of a movie off deserves a million awards.
Sidenote - for the score, I wasn’t as impressed as I thought I would be by the score, but it does carry the entire film, so no hard feelings if it gets the Oscar :).
Basically, if you love movies and like happiness, go see it!